California Nurses Rally Against Kaiser's $21.7 Billion In Excess Reserve And Endorse Health Insurance Rate Regulation Initiative To Return Billions Of Dollars To Patients, Says Consumer Watchdog Campaign


OAKLAND, Calif., May 6, 2014 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- At a rally and press conference today, Kaiser nurses and consumer advocates exposed the fact that Kaiser Permanente has accumulated a reserve that is $21.7 billion – 1626 percent – more than required by the state, while cutting patient care services and raising premiums on consumers. 

The California Nurses Association/National Nurses United, which has 85,000 California members, also announced its endorsement of a measure that will appear on this November's ballot to regulate health insurance rates in California, just as the state already regulates auto insurance rates.  The initiative can force refunds to consumers based on such excessive amounts held in reserve.

CNA Treasurer Martha Kuhl, RN noted that California registered nurses regularly "struggle to get our patients the care they need, including people facing financial ruin because of high insurance bills. Too often these struggles are over what the insurance company will pay rather than what is the best care option for patients. This November Californians can confront the bottom line mentality of insurance companies by passing this initiative to rein in these out of control price hikes."

Kaiser Oakland RN Katy Roemer decried Kaiser's recent rate hikes, which cost small group policyholders $18 million, and individuals $59 million, while cutting patient services.   

"Kaiser nurses cannot stand by quietly while Kaiser is hiking rates, cutting care and accumulating vast reserves and using patient care dollars to defeat an initiative that begins to bring some accountability into high prices that insurers impose on patients and families," said Roemer.

Kaiser increased its excess reserve, or tangible net equity, by $8.8 billion in 2013, according to state records. The latest filings show $21.68 billion in "TNE Excess."

In January Kaiser raised premium rates for individual policyholders by as much as 22 percent and for small business policyholders by as much as 56 percent.

The health insurance rate review and regulation ballot measure on November's ballot will allow for refunds if consumers have paid excessive rates since November 2012 and requires future rate hikes and benefit cuts to be justified.  The initiative allows the state to return excessive reserves to policyholders in the form of lower premiums.

"Kaiser has given more than $7.1 million against rate regulation because it wants to continue overcharging customers," said Jamie Court, proponent of the ballot measure and president of Consumer Watchdog. "Kaiser can raise rates at will today, but voters can force health insurance companies to justify rate hikes in the future and to return excessive premium dollars to customers."

To quantify the value of $21.7 billion, the advocates noted the amount:

  • Is larger than the GDP of 88 nations, per the UN 2012 - including Afghanistan, Honduras and Iceland.
  • Equals $2400 for each of Kaiser's 9 million members, or $3000 for each of Kaisers 7.2 million members in CA; or $571 for each of the 38 million residents of California, and
  • Dwarfs Governor Brown's 2014-15 proposed budget cut of $500 million for public health, and the entire state's annual $3.5 billion public health department budget.

More information about the initiative is at 

SOURCE Consumer Watchdog Campaign