Most Popular Stories
- Healthcare to add 4M jobs through 2018
- Behind the numbers: Best hospital list released, skepticism ensues
- Highest-risk mobile medical apps are focus of FDA's draft guidance
- Top 10 health systems named for 2011
- AHRQ: Less than half of hospitals have nonpunitive culture, safe handoffs
- More spending not equal to more patient satisfaction
- Patients pick hospitals for their social media presence
- Disney gives hospitals advice on consumer service
- Disney Institute Announces New Healthcare Service Program as Hospitals Prepare for Public Reporting of Patient Scores
- Hospitals hope to save money by pre-screening ER patients
- Hospitals spend up to $100M to scan paper
Featured Jobs
- EPIC Professionals: Over 150 Opportunities
Kelly Sercices, Inc. - Duhram, NC
Events
- HealthTech NextGeneration 2011
August 12, 2011 — San Francisco, CA - 2nd Annual Medical Management in Medicare Advantage: Payer/Provider Collaborative Care Summit
August 25-26, 2011 — Hyatt Regency Mission Bay Spa and Marina, San Diego, CA - Medical Device Connectivity Conference
Sept. 8-9, 2011 — Boston, MA - Position Your Practice: Future of ACOs & Payment Reform Webinar
July 21, 3 p.m. ET
Paid Research Reports
-
Electronic health records: getting it right first time
-
Cloud Computing Adoption In The APAC Life Sciences Industry
-
Stakeholder Opinions: Ophthalmology - Leading brands under threat
-
Genomics, Proteomics and Metabolomics in Diagnostics: Market landscape, innovative technologies and future outlook
-
Healthcare Regulatory Update: The United Arab Emirates
-
Point of Care Testing: Evaluating the return to evidence based medicine, novel technologies and the competitive landscape
Free Newsletter
Free Newsletter
FierceHealthPayer provides the latest news about the fast-changing and heavily regulated area of healthcare reimbursement. Join thousands of healthcare plan executives who get FierceHealthPayer via weekly email. Sign up today!
Top Tags
Highmark used anti-competitive actions in 'precedential' case
Highmark illegally conspired to reduce competition, raise prices and gain a monopoly on the Pittsburgh region's healthcare industry, according to a newly reinstated antitrust lawsuit against the health insurer and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC).
A U.S. District Court previously dismissed West Penn Allegheny Health System's antitrust claim. But a U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals panel, acting on an appeal from West Penn Allegheny, found ample grounds to proceed with the claim, according to the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. The appeals panel said the allegations "plausibly suggest ... anti-competitive conduct," reports the Lebanon Daily News.
Among the suit's claims, West Penn says UPMC refused to contract with other health insurance companies at reasonable rates and Highmark paid inflated reimbursements to UPMC's facilities, putting other insurers at an economic disadvantage.
According to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the court acknowledged that UPMC and Highmark may have:
- forged a deal to cancel Highmark's Community Blue product in return for UPMC undermining its own health insurance plan;
- refused West Penn's request to refinance a 2000 loan from Highmark even as the insurer began lending UPMC money to build a new Children's Hospital;
- arranged high insurance reimbursement rates for UPMC's services, and "artificially depressed" rates for West Penn's services; and
- reaped record profits during the period, which only ended when the Department of Justice began investigating the relationship between Highmark and UPMC.
The court stamped the cover sheet of the decision "precedential," a move signaling the panel wants the ruling to be considered a guide for future antitrust cases. "This is a big decision," lawyer Joseph Friedman told the Pittsburgh BusinessTimes. "This stands for some important antitrust principles that the Third Circuit wants future courts to take into consideration."
The appeals court is now expected to send the case back to U.S. District Court, which could then call a conference of the parties to discuss how to proceed.
Highmark responded to the court's action, saying it will continue to "vigorously fight" the claims and believes "it will prevail on the merits."
To learn more:
- read the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review article
- read the Lebanon Daily News story
- see the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette article
- see the Pittsburgh Business Times piece
Related Articles:
Antitrust legislation for health insurers now the big reform issue
DOJ, FTC issue new horizontal merger guidelines
DOJ sues BCBS in Michigan
DOJ investigating Partners HealthCare System for potential antitrust violations
Comments
Added to the above, Highmark also screws doctors by claiming to patients that the doctor was paid when in-fact the payment was never made. Slave labor. Pennsylvania and the Federal Government have done nothing about this. I bet if you scraped-up whale sh*t at the bottom of the ocean, Highmark's logo would be underneath it.
Post a comment
Home | Subscribe | Advertise | Mobile Edition | RSS | Privacy | Site Map | EditorsTHE FIERCEMARKETS NETWORKFierceEnergy | FierceSmartGrid | FierceFinance | FierceFinanceIT | FierceComplianceIT | FierceHealthcare | FierceHealthFinance | FierceHealthIT | Hospital Impact | FierceMobileHealthcare | FierceHealthPayer | FiercePracticeManagement | FierceEMR | FierceCIO | FierceCIO:TechWatch | FierceContentManagement | FierceMobileIT | FierceGovernmentIT | FierceGovernment | FierceHomelandSecurity | FierceBiotech | FierceBiotech Research | FiercePharma | FierceVaccines | FierceBiotechIT | FiercePharma Manufacturing | FierceMedicalDevices | FierceDrugDelivery | FierceIPTV | FierceOnlineVideo | FierceTelecom | FierceEnterpriseCommunications | FierceBroadbandWireless | FierceDeveloper | FierceMobileContent | FierceWireless | FierceWireless:Europe | FierceCable© 2011 FierceMarkets. All rights reserved. |